Commentary: India has a sexual assault problem only women can fix

Commentary: India has a sexual assault problem only women can fix

Having more female leaders in politics won't solve violence against women or other gender issues, but it can better protect vulnerable women from abuse, says one observer.

A woman walks past a portrait of J. Jayalalithaa, Chief Minister of the southern state of Tamil Nad
A woman walks past a portrait of J. Jayalalithaa, former Chief Minister of the southern state of Tamil Nadu, in Chennai, India, March 13, 2012. (Photo: REUTERS/Babu)

BOISE, Idaho: India is the most dangerous country for sexual violence against women, according to the Thomson Reuters Foundation 2018 survey.

The survey, which measures sexual and non-sexual violence, discrimination, cultural traditions, healthcare and human trafficking, has been criticised for reflecting more perception than data.

But India barely fares better in other studies that rank its treatment of women. It placed 131st of 152 countries in the Georgetown Institute’s global ranking of women’s inclusion and well-being.

India’s National Crime Records Bureau reported 338,954 crimes against women – including 38,947 rapes – in 2016, the most recent government data available. That’s up from 309,546 reported incidents of violence against women in 2013.

High-profile attacks on Indian women have shocked this nation of 1.3 billion in recent years. 

The 2012 gang rape of a 23-year-old student in Delhi who died from her injuries caused public outrage. The incident helped spur an amendment to India’s criminal law, which broadened the definition of sexual crimes against women to include stalking, acid attacks and voyeurism.

This year, Prime Minister Narendra Modi issued an executive order allowing the death penalty as a punishment for people convicted of sexually assaulting a child under 12.

READ: When children say they’ve been sexually abused, believe them, a commentary

But stricter laws apparently did little to prevent 34 girls from being tortured and raped at government-funded shelters in India’s Bihar state earlier this year.

WOMEN’S REPRESENTATION IN INDIA

My research on diversity in government suggests that one of the reasons India has not been able to effectively address crimes against women is the lack of women in national political office.

That’s because, research shows, having women in government can lead to more and better laws that safeguard women’s well-being.

Woman reacts at protest against rape of girl and teenager, in New Delhi
A woman reacts at a protest against the rape of an eight-year old girl, in Kathua, near Jammu and a teenager in Unnao, Uttar Pradesh state. (Photo: REUTERS/Cathal McNaughton)

India’s population is 48 per cent female. But women hold just under 12 per cent of seats in the national legislature.

That falls well below the 30 per cent “critical mass” that the United Nations Equal Opportunity Commission believes is necessary for women lawmakers to be influential in policymaking.

Local governments in India actually have a quota system that ensures women hold one-third of seats in rural and city councils. But female representation in India’s far more powerful national government remains comparable to countries like the Republic of Congo and Mauritius, where women hold about 11 per cent of legislative seats.

Rwanda, where 61 per cent of legislators are female, has the most women in government of any nation in the world, followed by Cuba, with 53 per cent.

These are not necessarily the safest places in the world for women. 

According to the Georgetown Institute’s ranking of women’s well-being, Iceland, Norway, Switzerland, Slovenia and Spain are some of the safest – all countries where women hold over 30 per cent of legislative seats.

Political representation does not translate precisely, directly or immediately into physical security for a given population. But it’s a start.

READ:  What took Singapore so long to move against marital immunity for rape? A commentary

WOMEN HELP WOMEN

Research demonstrates that governments that include representatives from across society – that is, of different political parties, races, classes, genders, geographies and religions – produce better quality of life for citizens than less inclusive governments.

Countries with a vibrant political party system enable diverse groups to influence decision-making. This is because they are a product of deliberation and cooperation between politicians with divergent ideologies, policies formulated in such societies are more likely to reflect the needs of diverse groups.

Scholarship likewise indicates that women in office may prioritise different kinds of policies than men – including those that address the needs of women and children.

FILE PHOTO - Bharti is administered oath of office by India's President Mukherjee as a cabinet
Uma Bharti, Union Minister for Sanitation and Drinking Water and former Madhya Pradesh chief minister, at the presidential palace in New Delhi May 26, 2014. (Photo: REUTERS/Adnan Abidi)

READ: For women of different cultures, classes, backgrounds and age – it’s still a man’s world, a commentary

In New Zealand, where women hold 38 per cent of parliamentary seats and the prime minister is a woman, lawmakers recently guaranteed paid leave for victims of domestic violence. That gives victims time to relocate, protecting themselves and their children from their abusers.

Women in the United States Congress have also proactively addressed sexual harassment inside government.

In March, female senators from both parties – who make up 22 per cent of the US Senate – pushed Senate leadership to call a vote on legislation that would give legal representation to women who complain of sexual harassment on Capitol Hill and reduce barriers to filing a formal complaint. 

The bill passed in May, and is currently being reconciled with the House’s version of a similar bill.

And it was the late chief minister of India’s Tamil Nadu state, J Jayalalithaa, who in 2010 announced a 13-point action plan for the state to better protect sexual violence survivors. 

Her provisions, which have since been partially implemented, included state-paid medical expenses after abuse, female investigating officers and fast-track courts for sexual violence cases.

READ: Sexual harassment in South Korea exposes hypocrisy and a culture of intimidation, a commentary

A sign supporting women's rights hangs on a tree before the start of an #IWillGoOut event, org
A sign supporting women's rights hangs on a tree before the start of an #IWillGoOut event, organised to show solidarity with the Women's March in Washington, inside a public park in Kolkata, India, January 21, 2017. (Photo: REUTERS/Rupak De Chowdhuri)

India’s 2013 national legislation on sexual violence ignores many of these victims’ rights issues, as the human rights organisations Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International have pointed out.

MORE WOMEN IN POLITICS NEEDED 

India has contemplated the need for more women in public office.

In 2010, the upper house of its legislature voted on a bill that would have designated one-third of seats in national and state legislative assemblies for women. Then-Prime Minister Manmohan Singh described it as a “historic step forward toward emancipation of Indian womanhood".

But the lower house never voted on the bill. And though Prime Minister Modi has expressed support for a gender quota in Indian government, he has made little effort to work with parliament to get the legislation passed.

Putting Indian women in positions of political power won’t solve a longstanding, pervasive and entrenched social issue like violence against women.

But evidence suggests that an Indian government with more women in it could better protect Indian women by passing comprehensive laws that defend women from abuse and help victims recover.

Nisha Bellinger is assistant professor of political science at Boise State University. A version of this commentary first appeared on The Conversation. Read it here.


Source: CNA/nr(sl)

Bookmark